I have been making an effort to catch up with books published in 2024, and here's my first installment. Despite admitting I am only an occasional mystery tale reader, everything in The Tainted Cup just seems to my eyes to be done enjoyably right, with sure-footed dialogue and vivid atmosphere. Within the first chapter we are introduced to two appealing main characters, the inspector of the Iudex, Ana, and her apprentice assistant, Din. A variation on Sherlock and Watson, this unlikely pair are plunged deep into a murder case and a conspiracy that will affect the Empire of Khanum.
We get some standard 'murder mystery' plot elements in the initial set up, weirdly macabre crimes and victims, some hidden secrets, a trail of clues and of course 'the hook': we as the reader increasingly want to know why the deaths have taken place. The backdrop is the setting of the sprawling Empire, with its division by wealth and privilege into 'circles'. The third circle is for the least fortunate, as it lies closest to the shoreline and its wall, imperilled by leviathan beasts resembling giant kaiju. Society is structured into layers, with the military, the aristocracy and elite power given to many through arcane 'grafts'. I found it quite accomplished science-fantasy world building.
Ana is the eccentric, mysterious and obsessed inspector, bent towards the investigation like a predatory dog after bone. As her apprentice, Din must take advantage of his own special power of 'engraving', and turn his taciturn manner and even a learning disability to his own advantage. Both Ana and Din show true integrity in their quest to resolve the central mystery. My favourite character, however, is the gruff old soldier, Miljin, who despite his brusque manner and world-weary wisdom often shows compassion and caring to the others.
There are a number of red herrings we meet along the way, and even some enemies revealed as hiding in plain sight. We eventually get to see the real story behind the shady aristocratic Hazas family, in their ruthless quest to increase their own power. And the dramatic revelations, mainly deduced by the delightfully nutty Ana, are given to us in a way that pleasingly resolves the questions we, as readers, wanted to ask. It's quite well-done how details in the sotry that previously seemed unimportant are brought back once more as vital clues in the final solving of the mystery. My only small gripe was some of the philosophizing about the Empire and the characters describing it in terms of metaphors, less might have better in this area.
Rating: 5 stars (out of 5)
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐